The Law Firm of Joel R. Brandes, P.C.
  • Home
  • Recent Decisions
  • Recent Legislation and Rules
  • Appeals to the Appellate Divison
    • Instructions for taking an Appeal to the Appellate Division
    • Who is served with the notice of appeal?
    • Registration and Consent to Efiling by Respondents Within 20 days of being served the notification of docket number
    • Preserving the Right to Appeal
    • Appellate Division is Single Statewide Court
    • Appeals to the Appellate Division as of Right from the Supreme Court
    • Permissible Appellant—“Aggrieved party” and Mootness doctrine
    • Permissible Appellant - Appealable Judgment or Order
    • Permissible Appellant - Appeal from Order denying motion with leave to renew or without prejudice
    • Appeals : Appellate Review of Non-final Orders in Matrimonial Actions
    • Appeals : Fundamental and Harmless Error
    • Appeals : Matrimonial Presumptions and the Burden of Proof
    • Appeals : Stare Decisis, Precedent and Dicta
    • Appeals : Understanding the Support Magistrate Objection Process
    • Appeals to the Appellate Division from Family Court
    • Perfecting the Appeal to the Appellate Division - Methods
    • Perfecting the Appeal to the Appellate Division - Appellate Division Bound by Record
    • Perfecting the Appeal to the Appellate Division - Order and Settle the Transcript
    • Method of Settlement of the Transcript
    • Appeals to Appellate Division from Supreme Court by permission
    • Form of Record and Briefs - Parties, Docket Number, Method of Reproduction
    • ​Form of Briefs and Appendices - CPLR
    • What must be in the Reproduced Full Record
    • What is the Judgment-roll?
    • What must be in the Appendix.
    • What must be in Briefs
    • Time, number and manner of filing of records, appendices and briefs
    • Cross appeals - Briefing Schedule, Joint Record, Content of Briefs, Time for Service
    • Extension of time to perfect appeal
    • Concurrent appeals, Appeals from a single order or judgment. Consolidation of Appeals.
    • First Department Requirement of note of issue
    • Stay of Enforcement of Order or Judgment Pending Appeal
    • Practice in the Appellate Division: What Laws Govern
    • Practice Rules of the Appellate Divison: Joint & Local Rules
    • Practice in the Appellate Division First Department New and Amended Local Rules June 25, 2021
    • Practice in the Appellate Division, First Department, Frequently asked questions
    • Practice in the Appellate Divison: Motions in the First Department
    • Practice in the Appellate Divison: Motions in the Second Department
    • Practice in the Appellate Division: Motions in the Third Department
    • Practice In The Appellate Division:Motions in the Fourth Department
    • Instructions for Taking an Appeal Frequently Asked Questions
    • Instructions for Perfecting an Appeal to the Appellate Division
    • Instructions to Perfect an Appeal in the Third Department
    • Instructions to perfect an appeal in the Fourth Department
    • Appellate Division Fourth Department Q & A
    • Universal E-filing in the Fourth Department
    • Standards of Appellate Review in Matrimonial Actions
    • Standard of Review— Appellate review of Custody Determinations
    • Standard of Review of Custody Determinations - Effect of Changed Circumstances During Pendency of Appeal
    • Standards of Review : Fugative disentitlement doctrine in custody and child support appealsw Page
    • Mandatory Electronic filing (e-filing): First Department
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): First Department Digital submission in Non-Efiled Matters - June 1, 2020
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): First Department New and Amended Local Rules Updated June 25, 2021
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): First Department Formatting Specifications
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): First Department Frequently Asked Questions
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): Second Department Technical Guidelines
    • Mandatory Electronic filing (e-filing): Second Department
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): First Department Motions Frequently Asked Questions
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): Second Department - Motions -22 NYCRR 670.4 (d)
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): Third Department - Digital Copies - 22 NYCRR 850.4 (a)
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): Third Department Motion FAQs
    • Mandatory Electronic filing (e-filing): Fourth Department
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): Fourth Department Motion FAQS
    • Electronic filing Authorization in matrimonial actions
    • E-filing Rules and Forms of the Appellate Division
    • Joel R. Brandes Reported Appeals
  • Court of Appeals Rules of Practice
  • How to take an Appeal to the Court of Appeals
  • I. Appeals as of Right
  • II. Motions for Leave to Appeal
  • III. Guidelines for Preparing a Motion for Leave to AppeaNew Page
  • IV. Rule 500.11 Review Aternate Procedure for Selected Appeals
  • V. Appealability and Reviewability
  • VI. What is a Final Determination
  • VII. The "Necessarily Affects" Requirement
  • Filing of record material and briefs in normal course appeals and required copies
  • Contents of Records, appendices and exhibits in normal course appeals
  • Content and form of Briefs in normal course appeals
  • Civil and Criminal Appeals Frequently Asked Questions
  • Civil Motions Frequently Asked Questions
  • Court-Pass - Digital Filing Frequently Asked Questions
  • Court of Appeals Portal for uploading companion digital submissions
  • Court of Appeals Court Pass Public Access and Search
  • New York Divorce Law
    • Agreements Before & During Marriage
    • Custody & Visitation
    • Child Support Awards
    • Counsel Fee Awards
    • Enforcement of Judgments & Orders
    • Equitable Distribution
    • Equitable Distribution Law for Trial Counsel
    • Equitable Distribution Decisions Chart
    • Exclusive Occupancy of Marital Home
    • Grounds for Divorce
    • Maintenance Awards until 2016
    • Maintenance Awards after January 22, 2016
    • Modification of Maintenance and Child Support Orders and Judgments
    • Orders of Protection
    • Special Relief - Insurance
    • Spousal Support Awards
    • Table of Effective dates of Revisions to Domestic Relations Law §§ 236, 237, and 240
    • Timetable For Service of Motion Papers
    • Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction & Enforcement Act
  • Additional Articles and Information about New York Divorce & Family Law
    • Adoption Information
    • Antenuptial and Post Nuptial Agreements
    • Child Abuse & Prevention
    • Child Custody & Parental Alienation Information
    • Child Support
    • Common Law Marriage
    • Child Visitation Supervisors
    • Degrees & Licenses
    • Domestic Violence
    • Emergency Court Applications
    • Engagement gifts
    • Evidence Law
    • Family Court Proceedings
    • Federal Law Divorce Resources (Pension and Social Security)
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Grandparent and Non-Parent Visitation
    • Grounds for Divorce
    • Legal Fees, Liens & Sanctions
    • Litigation & Procedure
    • Maintenance and Child Support New York Court System Tools
    • Maintenance, Special Relief & Spousal Support
    • Marital Property and Property Distribution
    • New York Motion Practice
    • Professional Conduct
    • Retirement Benefits
    • Questions about Income Tax
    • Right to Counsel in Matrimonial Action
    • Role of the Attorney for the Child
    • Valuation Aids
  • ​New York Court System Links for Lawyers
  • New York Court Rules
  • New York Court Websites and Decisions
  • Electronic Filing in Supreme Court Rules and FAQ's
  • Using EDDS Electronic Delivery to Courts
  • New York Courts Case Search Page for E-filed Case Files
  • New York Court System Site Map
  • Family Court Official Forms
  • International Child Abduction Remedies
    • International Child Abduction
    • Hague International Child Abduction Convention cases from 2011 to date.
    • Hague international Child Abduction Table of Reported and Unreported Cases from 1988 until 2010
  • Site Map of The Law Firm of Joel R. Brandes PC website
  • Make an Appointment for a Consultation
    • Consultation Fee Payment
  • Joel R. Brandes Curriculum vitae
  • Subscribe to our newsletter
  • About Us
  • Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Standard of Review of Custody Determinations - Effect of Changed Circumstances during pendency of appeal

Standard of Review of custody determinations—Effect of changed circumstances during pendency of appeal
 
          The Court of Appeals has held that the court may consider new developments that occur during the pendency of a custody appeal. “To ignore these new developments would exalt the procedural rule, important though it is, to a point of absurdity, and reflect no credit on the judicial process.” Changed circumstances may have particular significance in child custody matters, and the Court may take notice of the new facts and allegations to the extent they indicate that the record before it is no longer sufficient for determining an appellant's fitness and right to custody.1
          In Matter of Michael B.,2 the Court of Appeals was informed during the pendency of the appeal that the appellant was charged with, and admitted, neglect of the children in his custody (not Michael), and that those children had been removed from his home and were again in the custody of the Commissioner of the Social Services. The neglect petitions alleged that appellant abused alcohol and controlled substances including cocaine, and physically abused the children. Orders of fact finding had been entered by Family Court recognizing appellant's admission in open court to “substance abuse, alcohol and cocaine abuse” and an Order of Protection was entered prohibiting appellant from visiting the children while under the influence of drugs or alcohol. The Court of Appeals rejected Appellant's request that it ignore these new developments and grant him custody because matters outside the record cannot be considered by an appellate court. It held that to ignore these new developments would exalt the procedural rule, important though it is, to a point of absurdity, and reflect no credit on the judicial process. It held that changed circumstances may have particular significance in child custody matters,3 and that the Court would therefore take notice of the new facts and allegations to the extent they indicated that the record before it was no longer sufficient for determining appellant's fitness and right to custody of Michael. It remitted the matter to Family Court for a new hearing and determination of those issues.4
          We note that prior to the Court of Appeals decision in Matter of Michael B.,5 appellate courts have considered changed circumstances since the date of the determination appealed from where the circumstances of the case warranted it.6
 
 Endnotes


1 Matter of Michael B., 80 N.Y.2d 299, 317–18, 590 N.Y.S.2d 60, 604 N.E.2d 122 (1992)..

2 Matter of Michael B., 80 N.Y.2d 299, 317–318, 590 N.Y.S.2d 60, 604 N.E.2d 122 (1992).

3 Citing Braiman v. Braiman, 44 N.Y.2d 584, 587, 509, 407 N.Y.S.2d 449, 378 N.E.2d 1019 (1978); Matter of Angela D., 175 A.D.2d 244, 245, 572 N.Y.S.2d 710 (2d Dep't 1991); In re M., 40 A.D.2d 546, 334 N.Y.S.2d 204 (2d Dep't 1972).

4 Matter of Michael B., 80 N.Y.2d 299, 317–318, 590 N.Y.S.2d 60, 604 N.E.2d 122 (1992).

5 Matter of Michael B., 80 N.Y.2d 299, 317–318, 590 N.Y.S.2d 60, 604 N.E.2d 122 (1992).

6 In Braiman v. Braiman, 44 N.Y.2d 584, 590–92, 407 N.Y.S.2d 449, 378 N.E.2d 1019 (1978) the Court of Appeals held that although the joint custody award could not stand, that did not resolve the issue. The Court of Appeals does not make new findings of fact. “Instead, the court reviews the record and chooses only between the findings of the courts below.” The conflicts and contradictions in this record, however, were so severe and so went to the heart of the matter that it was impossible to resolve them without assessments of credibility. The state of this particular record made resolution, of the conflicting facts hopeless. “An added difficulty was that two years had elapsed since the hearing and during that period, the boys had lived with their father; they had been prevented from seeing their mother; and the mother had evidently found it necessary to conceal her whereabouts.” In light of all that had occurred and the critical inconsistencies in the record, a new but expedited hearing was required. On appellate review, the present record was incapable of sustaining a plausible resolution. The order of the Appellate Division was reversed and a new hearing ordered..
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Recent Decisions
  • Recent Legislation and Rules
  • Appeals to the Appellate Divison
    • Instructions for taking an Appeal to the Appellate Division
    • Who is served with the notice of appeal?
    • Registration and Consent to Efiling by Respondents Within 20 days of being served the notification of docket number
    • Preserving the Right to Appeal
    • Appellate Division is Single Statewide Court
    • Appeals to the Appellate Division as of Right from the Supreme Court
    • Permissible Appellant—“Aggrieved party” and Mootness doctrine
    • Permissible Appellant - Appealable Judgment or Order
    • Permissible Appellant - Appeal from Order denying motion with leave to renew or without prejudice
    • Appeals : Appellate Review of Non-final Orders in Matrimonial Actions
    • Appeals : Fundamental and Harmless Error
    • Appeals : Matrimonial Presumptions and the Burden of Proof
    • Appeals : Stare Decisis, Precedent and Dicta
    • Appeals : Understanding the Support Magistrate Objection Process
    • Appeals to the Appellate Division from Family Court
    • Perfecting the Appeal to the Appellate Division - Methods
    • Perfecting the Appeal to the Appellate Division - Appellate Division Bound by Record
    • Perfecting the Appeal to the Appellate Division - Order and Settle the Transcript
    • Method of Settlement of the Transcript
    • Appeals to Appellate Division from Supreme Court by permission
    • Form of Record and Briefs - Parties, Docket Number, Method of Reproduction
    • ​Form of Briefs and Appendices - CPLR
    • What must be in the Reproduced Full Record
    • What is the Judgment-roll?
    • What must be in the Appendix.
    • What must be in Briefs
    • Time, number and manner of filing of records, appendices and briefs
    • Cross appeals - Briefing Schedule, Joint Record, Content of Briefs, Time for Service
    • Extension of time to perfect appeal
    • Concurrent appeals, Appeals from a single order or judgment. Consolidation of Appeals.
    • First Department Requirement of note of issue
    • Stay of Enforcement of Order or Judgment Pending Appeal
    • Practice in the Appellate Division: What Laws Govern
    • Practice Rules of the Appellate Divison: Joint & Local Rules
    • Practice in the Appellate Division First Department New and Amended Local Rules June 25, 2021
    • Practice in the Appellate Division, First Department, Frequently asked questions
    • Practice in the Appellate Divison: Motions in the First Department
    • Practice in the Appellate Divison: Motions in the Second Department
    • Practice in the Appellate Division: Motions in the Third Department
    • Practice In The Appellate Division:Motions in the Fourth Department
    • Instructions for Taking an Appeal Frequently Asked Questions
    • Instructions for Perfecting an Appeal to the Appellate Division
    • Instructions to Perfect an Appeal in the Third Department
    • Instructions to perfect an appeal in the Fourth Department
    • Appellate Division Fourth Department Q & A
    • Universal E-filing in the Fourth Department
    • Standards of Appellate Review in Matrimonial Actions
    • Standard of Review— Appellate review of Custody Determinations
    • Standard of Review of Custody Determinations - Effect of Changed Circumstances During Pendency of Appeal
    • Standards of Review : Fugative disentitlement doctrine in custody and child support appealsw Page
    • Mandatory Electronic filing (e-filing): First Department
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): First Department Digital submission in Non-Efiled Matters - June 1, 2020
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): First Department New and Amended Local Rules Updated June 25, 2021
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): First Department Formatting Specifications
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): First Department Frequently Asked Questions
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): Second Department Technical Guidelines
    • Mandatory Electronic filing (e-filing): Second Department
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): First Department Motions Frequently Asked Questions
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): Second Department - Motions -22 NYCRR 670.4 (d)
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): Third Department - Digital Copies - 22 NYCRR 850.4 (a)
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): Third Department Motion FAQs
    • Mandatory Electronic filing (e-filing): Fourth Department
    • Electronic filing (e-filing): Fourth Department Motion FAQS
    • Electronic filing Authorization in matrimonial actions
    • E-filing Rules and Forms of the Appellate Division
    • Joel R. Brandes Reported Appeals
  • Court of Appeals Rules of Practice
  • How to take an Appeal to the Court of Appeals
  • I. Appeals as of Right
  • II. Motions for Leave to Appeal
  • III. Guidelines for Preparing a Motion for Leave to AppeaNew Page
  • IV. Rule 500.11 Review Aternate Procedure for Selected Appeals
  • V. Appealability and Reviewability
  • VI. What is a Final Determination
  • VII. The "Necessarily Affects" Requirement
  • Filing of record material and briefs in normal course appeals and required copies
  • Contents of Records, appendices and exhibits in normal course appeals
  • Content and form of Briefs in normal course appeals
  • Civil and Criminal Appeals Frequently Asked Questions
  • Civil Motions Frequently Asked Questions
  • Court-Pass - Digital Filing Frequently Asked Questions
  • Court of Appeals Portal for uploading companion digital submissions
  • Court of Appeals Court Pass Public Access and Search
  • New York Divorce Law
    • Agreements Before & During Marriage
    • Custody & Visitation
    • Child Support Awards
    • Counsel Fee Awards
    • Enforcement of Judgments & Orders
    • Equitable Distribution
    • Equitable Distribution Law for Trial Counsel
    • Equitable Distribution Decisions Chart
    • Exclusive Occupancy of Marital Home
    • Grounds for Divorce
    • Maintenance Awards until 2016
    • Maintenance Awards after January 22, 2016
    • Modification of Maintenance and Child Support Orders and Judgments
    • Orders of Protection
    • Special Relief - Insurance
    • Spousal Support Awards
    • Table of Effective dates of Revisions to Domestic Relations Law §§ 236, 237, and 240
    • Timetable For Service of Motion Papers
    • Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction & Enforcement Act
  • Additional Articles and Information about New York Divorce & Family Law
    • Adoption Information
    • Antenuptial and Post Nuptial Agreements
    • Child Abuse & Prevention
    • Child Custody & Parental Alienation Information
    • Child Support
    • Common Law Marriage
    • Child Visitation Supervisors
    • Degrees & Licenses
    • Domestic Violence
    • Emergency Court Applications
    • Engagement gifts
    • Evidence Law
    • Family Court Proceedings
    • Federal Law Divorce Resources (Pension and Social Security)
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Grandparent and Non-Parent Visitation
    • Grounds for Divorce
    • Legal Fees, Liens & Sanctions
    • Litigation & Procedure
    • Maintenance and Child Support New York Court System Tools
    • Maintenance, Special Relief & Spousal Support
    • Marital Property and Property Distribution
    • New York Motion Practice
    • Professional Conduct
    • Retirement Benefits
    • Questions about Income Tax
    • Right to Counsel in Matrimonial Action
    • Role of the Attorney for the Child
    • Valuation Aids
  • ​New York Court System Links for Lawyers
  • New York Court Rules
  • New York Court Websites and Decisions
  • Electronic Filing in Supreme Court Rules and FAQ's
  • Using EDDS Electronic Delivery to Courts
  • New York Courts Case Search Page for E-filed Case Files
  • New York Court System Site Map
  • Family Court Official Forms
  • International Child Abduction Remedies
    • International Child Abduction
    • Hague International Child Abduction Convention cases from 2011 to date.
    • Hague international Child Abduction Table of Reported and Unreported Cases from 1988 until 2010
  • Site Map of The Law Firm of Joel R. Brandes PC website
  • Make an Appointment for a Consultation
    • Consultation Fee Payment
  • Joel R. Brandes Curriculum vitae
  • Subscribe to our newsletter
  • About Us
  • Terms of Use and Privacy Policy